SP-3300 Flight Research at Ames,
1940-1997
Epilogue
[79] This history of
flight research beginning at the NACA's Ames Aeronautical Laboratory
in 1940 and continuing to this day at NASA's Ames Research Center has
covered a wide range of technical areas that include icing research;
transonic model testing; aerodynamics research; flying qualities,
stability and control, and performance evaluations; variable
stability aircraft; gunsight tracking and guidance and control
displays; in-flight thrust reversing and steep approach research;
boundary-layer control research; STOL and V/STOL aircraft research;
and rotorcraft research. The flight research came about in many cases
as the result of a progressive development of ideas through stages of
analyses, wind tunnel, and ground-based simulator tests in Ames
facilities. In fact, the collaborative efforts using this combination
of facilities led to a more substantive result than would have been
the case had the flight experiments been conducted in isolation.
Several national awards were presented to Ames pilots and engineers
in recognition of their achievements in pursuit of these research
objectives. The significant contributions that came about as a result
of these various programs are listed below.
- Prototypes of the Ames anti-icing system
were evaluated in the B-17 and B-24 heavy bombers from the WWII
era. A substantive program on the C-46 Commando icing research
aircraft led to the definition of icing-system design
criteria.
- Qualitative aerodynamic data in the
transonic regime were obtained through tests of small wing-mounted
and drop models.
- The effects of compressibility on
aerodynamics, including pitch-up, shock-induced buffet, and
aileron buzz were established.
- The YF-93A aircraft was the first to use
flush NACA engine inlets and was tested extensively with both
scoop and flush inlets.
- Drag characteristics of tailless delta
winged aircraft were documented in flight and compared with wind
tunnel data.
- Results from flight tests of the Ogee wing
planform were provided to the Anglo-French team that was in the
process of designing the Concorde supersonic transport, giving
them assurance that the configuration was suitable for that
aircraft.
- Data from wake-vortex penetration tests
were generalized to form the basis for the FAA's separation
criteria for aircraft landing behind large, heavy aircraft.
- Extensive results were obtained concerning
the stability and control characteristics that influence the
acceptable approach speed, providing an understanding of the
selection of approach speed for high-performance aircraft.
- A standardized system for rating flying
qualities was developed that accounted for the demands of the
flight task and the behavior of the aircraft and pilot in
accomplishing the task to the expected degree of precision. The
Cooper-Harper rating scale has been one of the enduring
contributions of flying-qualities research over the past 40
years.
- [80] The world's first
variable stability aircraft was developed and, along with several
successors, contributed extensive data for use in defining flying
qualities design criteria, as well as in assessing the flying
qualities of numerous individual aircraft designs.
- A head-up guidance display was
demonstrated at Ames in a Boeing 727-100 transport airplane and
was subsequently adapted by the industry and certificated for
civil transport operations.
- In-flight thrust reversing was evaluated
with the F-94C Starfire fighter. The thrust-reversing concept was
applied eventually to DC-8 transport aircraft to achieve the rapid
descent capability required for commercial transport
certification.
- A direct lift-control system was
demonstrated to engineers and pilots of the airline industry. The
design was incorporated as part of the Lockheed L-1011 commercial
airliner's flight control system, and was particularly effective
in achieving excellent automatic landing performance for that
aircraft.
- Flight tests with the JF-104 Starfighter
developed steep approach profiles now used by the space
shuttle.
- Approach and landing tests provided basic
design data for the space shuttle configuration control and the
guidance and navigation systems, a demonstration of digital
autopilot technology, and supported the decision to remove
air-breathing engines from the final shuttle design.
- Extensive data on fully blown leading-edge
and trailing-edge flaps were obtained in flight tests of the
F-100A Super Sabre. The experience gained from this testing went
into blown flap systems used on the F-104 Starfighter and the F-4
Phantom II.
- The Augmentor Wing Jet STOL Research
Aircraft, the first jet STOL transport, was used in a joint
NASA/Canadian Department of Industry, Trade and Commerce project
to demonstrate the concept in the low-speed regime and in
terminal-area operations. The aircraft was also used for
evaluating flying qualities criteria, augmented controls, flight
director concepts, and an automatic approach and landing system
that allowed pilots to exploit the vehicle's unique STOL
capabilities in terminal-area operations. The Augmentor Wing
performed a flight demonstration of a nonlinear inverse control
concept applied to a full flight envelope autopilot.
- The Quiet Short-Haul Research Aircraft
(QSRA) design used upper-surface blowing to achieve short-field
takeoff and landing performance. The aircraft documented stable
flight at lift levels three times those generated on conventional
aircraft and demonstrated operations aboard the aircraft carrier
U.S.S. Kitty Hawk without need for launch catapults or landing
arresting gear. The aircraft was also used to evaluate integrated
flightpath/airspeed controls and displays for making precision
instrument approaches and landings. The Air Force developed flying
qualities specifications for the C-17 long-range, heavy transport
based on the results of the earlier Ames Augmentor Wing and QSRA
research.
- [81] Extensive flight
testing was carried out on the X-14 jet vertical takeoff and
landing (VTOL) aircraft to investigate a range of flying qualities
in hover and transition flight and to evaluate lateral thrust
vectoring control. Research with this aircraft contributed to the
military's V/STOL flying qualities specification and played an
important role in the control system development of the Harrier
prototype.
- The XV-15 tilt rotor was the first
proof-of-concept vehicle built entirely to Ames' specifications.
This aircraft became the subject of a series of technology
development activities over the next decade. The work included
flying qualities and stability and control evaluations, control
law development, side-stick controller tests, performance
evaluations in all flight modes, acoustics tests, flow surveys,
and documentation of its loads, structural dynamics, and
aeroelastic stability characteristics. The XV-15 provided the
foundation necessary for the initiation of the V-22 Osprey program
for the Marines and for current development of the Bell 609 civil
tilt rotor.
- Research with the modified YAV-8B Harrier
was used to develop flying qualities criteria and control system
and display concepts for future STOVL fighter aircraft as part of
the Joint Strike Fighter program. It also demonstrated display
technology that is being implemented in the AV-8B Harrier II for
shipboard operation. Its complex digital, fly-by-wire control
system was designed, developed, and installed in the YAV-8B by an
Ames team.
- The X-36 unmanned scale model tailless
fighter demonstrated excellent stability and maneuverability up to
stall angle of attack.
- The UH-1H helicopter was used to develop
and evaluate control systems that would permit fully automatic
flight for helicopters. The first demonstration of automatic
control laws for a helicopter, developed using nonlinear inverse
methods was conducted on the aircraft. Flying qualities
experiments provided criteria used in the Army's helicopter flying
qualities specification that was developed primarily at Ames, as
well as control and display requirements for civil instrument
flight operations.
- The CH-47B Chinook was used by the Army
and NASA as a variable stability helicopter. The in-flight
simulation capability permitted a wide variety of flight
experiments that ranged from investigations in support of the
Army's flying qualities specification to the evaluation of
advanced multi-input, multi-output control laws.
- A UH-60 Black Hawk with sophisticated
blade instrumentation was used to acquire extensive rotor-load
data. Approximately 30 gigabytes of data were obtained and
installed in an electronic database that was immediately
accessible to the U.S. industry.
- A JUH-60A Black Hawk helicopter, known as
RASCAL, was modified to incorporate extensive vehicle and
rotor-system instrumentation, a digital research flight control
system, a real-time stereo-video passive ranging system, and a
sophisticated on-board image generation system. A principal focus
of the RASCAL helicopter work is to develop advanced flight
control designs to improve the agility of military
[82] rotorcraft, while also providing the pilot with
carefree maneuvering within an automatically protected flight
envelope.
- Two Cobra helicopters hosted Ames crew
station and human factors flight research experiments. One of
these aircraft has been used extensively in joint NASA/Army human
factors research in the area of visual and auditory
displays.
- A YO-3A aircraft, modified by the Army and
NASA to allow accurate in-flight measurement of rotorcraft
impulsive noise, contributed to the source selection of two Army
helicopter programs. A second YO-3A was used extensively by NASA
for rotorcraft acoustics research.
At this writing, most areas of flight research
have once again been transferred to the NASA Dryden Flight Research
Center. An exception to this directive has allowed rotorcraft flight
research to continue at Ames with aircraft operated by the U.S. Army.
Three aircraft will continue in the Ames inventory to carry on the
flight research tradition at the Center. These are the two UH-60
Black Hawk helicopters (NASA 748 and 750) and the NAH-1S Cobra (NASA
736). Research in the future will be conducted as part of a joint
NASA/Army rotorcraft technology program and will focus on advanced
controls and cockpit interfaces with these aircraft. NASA 750 will
continue to serve in the role as an in-flight simulator as
well.
To conclude this history, we would like to
recognize the three Ames aeronautical research pilots who lost their
lives in carrying out their professional duties. Ryland Carter, Rudy
Van Dyke, and Don Heinle were all highly accomplished pilots who were
fearless in pursuit of their test objectives. They were respected and
appreciated by their colleagues of the day and are remembered today
as men who made significant contributions to aeronautical technology
through their skill and daring.
[83]
Ames Research Center, Moffett Field,
California, circa 1995.

