[567] Since this book is amply footnoted by chapter, and since so little is generally known about the recently constituted archives that provided most of my source material, I have chosen to provide readers with the following general-purpose guide to the major sources for research into NACA history at NASA Langley Research Center instead of with the traditional bibliographic essay. Those seeking guidance about historiography relevant to the NACA or about other archival collections with significant NACA materials in them should consult Alex Roland's Guide to Research in NASA History, 4th ed. (Washington: NASA History Office, 1984), or the extended bibliographic essay in Roland's Model Research: The National Advisory Committee for Aeronautics, 1915-1958, NASA SP-4103 (Washington, 1985), 1:300-305, both of which are richly informative and analytical.
Langley Research Center, the oldest laboratory of the NACA and NASA, possesses an historical collection that in combination with its technical library rivals any archives for aerospace history in this country. In Langley's archives (see diagram) are collections of rare books and photographs, technical reports, office memoranda, flight and wind tunnel logs, programs and minutes of major technical conferences, personal papers, transcripts of interviews with key personnel, as well as scale models of aircraft and spacecraft and other illuminating artifacts. Besides storing Langley's own historical records, the archives also include important files of the Wallops Island (Va.) rocket test range, created in 1945 as an auxiliary base of Langley laboratory and managed by Langley as part of the Pilotless Aircraft Research Division (PARD) until 1958, when Wallops achieved independent status as a NASA center.
The four most important collections in the Langley archives are (1) the NACA correspondence files, (2) the NACA research authorization files, (3) the Milton Ames Collection, and (4) the personal papers of Floyd L. Thompson and John Stack. Since they are so important, these four collections will be described fully below. Key aspects of Langley's Floyd L. Thompson Technical Library are also discussed.
Anyone who plans to do research in an organization's archives should first ask some questions about the correspondence policy in force for that organization's employees: Could they send letters directly to outside addresses? Did all letters have to go through a central office? What management official, if any, had to "sign off" the letters? Knowing the peculiarities of the correspondence policies will make it much easier to evaluate and utilize the records.
In Langley's case, a superb historical archive was created as the by-product of a tight-to-the-vest correspondence policy and a highly centralized filing system. Largely as a result of the early and continuing control by NACA executive secretary John F. Victory over the lab's bureaucratic affairs (see chapter 2), all of its outgoing correspondence was reviewed and revised up through the division level until sanctioned in its final form by the office of the chief of research; then it was signed by the engineer-in-charge, the top......

[569] .....man in the laboratory organization. Incoming letters to individuals were routed directly to them, but only after being opened by the mail clerks. Copies of all letters, incoming and outgoing, were made for central files. Each letter was placed into one or more subject files, which were organized according to an alphanumeric code unique to Langley. Within each subject, papers were then arranged by date.
There are two catalogs to the correspondence file codes in the Langley archives, one that is alphabetical by subject and the other that follows the alphanumeric code; both are the products of the lab's mail filing operation. To illustrate the nature of these catalogs, the contents of their respective first pages are reproduced below.
|
Subject |
Code Number |
|
. | |
|
Aberdeen Proving Grounds |
B10-3 |
|
Accelerometers |
A184-8A |
|
Accident Investigation Board-Langley |
El-11 |
|
Accidents-Ames |
El-12 |
|
Accidents-Lewis |
El-17 |
|
Accidents-Edwards |
AF252-2 |
|
Accidents-Langley |
AF252-1 |
|
Acoustics |
A3134 |
|
Administrative Policy and Procedure |
E30-12C |
|
Advanced Research Projects Agency (ARPA) |
E20-6 |
|
Advisory Group for Aeronautical R&D (AGARD) |
E2-12B |
|
Aerial Spraying |
B10-1 |
|
Aeroelasticity |
A178-2 |
|
Aero Medical Association |
E34-17 |
|
Aeronautical Symbols |
E1-13 |
|
Aerospace Industries Association |
E6-7 |
|
Agriculture Department |
B10-1 |
|
Air Force |
B10-2 |
|
Aircraft Companies-General |
A173-4 |
|
Alsos Mission |
E2-12C |
|
Altimeters |
A184-8H |
|
Aluminum and Aluminum Alloys |
A311-2 |
|
Ames Research Center |
B10-6 |
|
Angle of Attack-Instruments |
A184-8D |
|
Antennas (Radio) |
A173-7 |
|
Apprentice Program |
C48-25 |
|
Code |
Subject |
|
. | |
|
A170-1 |
Aerodynamic Theory |
|
A172-1 |
Aerodynamics Committee Langley |
|
A173-1 |
Airfoils |
|
A173-1A |
Wings-Swept (Back and Forward) |
|
A173-2 |
Research Equipment Facilities (American Non-NACA) |
|
A173-2A |
Equipment (NACA) on Loan to Outside Sources |
|
A173-5 |
Airplanes-General |
|
A173-5A |
Hypersonic Aircraft |
|
A173-5B |
Helicopters-General |
|
A173-5C |
Privately Owned, Personal or Light Aircraft |
|
A173-5D |
Atomic Energy Commission |
|
A173-5E |
Airplanes-Disposition |
|
A173-5F |
Windshields and Cockpit Visibility Problems |
|
A173-5H |
Coupled Airplanes |
|
A173-5J |
Convertiplanes (Vertically Rising Aircraft, Except Helicopters) |
|
A173-5K |
Quarterly Status Reports on Projects Relating to Research Airplanes |
|
A173-5L |
Ground Cushion Phenomena |
|
A173-5M |
Use of Center Airplanes |
|
A173-5N |
NASA Aircraft Utilization Reports |
|
A173-5P |
Air Traffic Control |
|
A173-5R |
Integrated Programs for Aerospace Vehicle Design (IPAD) |
|
A173-6 |
Bombs |
Langley's correspondence files are a largely untapped reservoir for aerospace history. Only a few weeks before this book went to press I found in this collection, for example, the following letter, dated the eighth of July 1920. It was addressed to Leigh Griffith, Langley's first engineer-in-charge, and was written by a young man in California who was just getting into the aircraft business: Donald W. Douglas, the soon-to-be-famous airplane designer.
Brief further research indicates that Griffith went out of his way to help Douglas find a suitable supercharger. He sent the young airplane designer an assembly drawing showing the NACA Root-type supercharger as applied to a Liberty engine (an application which had never actually been made), but he advised him against using this particular device on Douglas's proposed airplane because the device was still in a preliminary test phase of design.
[572] The information in this letter very likely fits into the history of Douglas's round-the-world biplanes, the famous "World Cruisers" of 1924, which constituted his company's first big order. In any case, the letter exemplifies the valuable and yet-to-be-used historical information in the correspondence files of the Langley archives.
Although the correspondence files are tremendously valuable, the single most important source for aeronautical history at Langley is the NACA research authorization files. These files permit the historian to recreate the entire NACA research procedure for a given project from the raw research idea through the final polished report.
What exactly was an NACA research authorization? Whenever a project for research at Langley was approved by NACA headquarters, a research authorization (or RA) was signed by the chairman of the executive committee and forwarded to the lab for execution. Technically Langley was supposed to have an RA for each of its investigations, and each RA was expected to lead to the publication of an NACA report. Each RA had a title and a number, and each included information on the how and why of the investigation. Sometimes this information was stated very briefly and rather vaguely; other times it was expressed at great length and in detail. From the time of the authorization on, a copy of any letter or document, incoming or outgoing, that in any way concerned the subject of the RA was filed chronologically in the specific RA folder (as well as in the appropriate correspondence files). Thus by studying the RA files one can get a pretty clear idea of how the NACA went about its business. The files shed light on such things as the respective roles of headquarters and the lab in selecting and conducting research projects, the publications policies of the Committee, and the relations of NACA staff members with clients and colleagues.
Since there are over 2000 research authorization files, this collection provides virtually virgin territory for historical research. I looked in detail only at two or three dozen RA files. In preparation for Model Research, Alex Roland examined, I presume, about the same number. Clearly scholars have so far only scratched the surface of this prime source for NACA history.
The RA files are maintained in sequence in the archives from RA No. 1, "Comparison of mathematical analysis and model tests of air propellers," issued 18 July 1918, through RA No. 1584, "Free-fall tests to determine stability derivatives of Dove guided missile," issued 24 November 1950. (RAs after 1950, at present stored elsewhere, will be moved into the archives.) In the archive there is also a card file to the RA collection that cross-references subjects and titles of technical reports with RA numbers and the file codes of correspondence.
Still, the RA files are not easy to work with. Because of the vague and rather indiscriminate nature of the majority of RA titles and the built-in flexibility of RA procedure (discussed in chapter 2), it can be very hard now for anyone, even the talented and experienced Langley file clerks and librarians, to match individual research projects to the specific RA, or RAs, that covered them administratively. The best example of this difficulty during research for this book was my attempt to find the RA covering the preparation of the "Theory of Wing Sections of Arbitrary Shape," an important paper written by Langley physicist Theodore Theodorsen in 1931 and published by the NACA as tech. rpt. (TR) 411. (The contents of this paper are analyzed in chapter 4.)
On the day I was working on this problem, veteran Langley engineer Axel T. Mattson visited my office, and I enlisted his help to solve it. The logical first step was to identify all [573] RAs originating before 1931 whose titles most closely matched the subject of Theodorsen's paper. With Mattson's help, I narrowed down the possibilities to nine RAs, all of which in one way or another concerned airfoils or wing sections:
We deemed RA 254, "Investigation of methods of developing airfoil shapes to obtain desired characteristics," our best chance, as it matched the subject of Theodorsen's paper most closely, and then ranked the other eight RAs in order of our evaluation of their relevancy.
One by one we pulled dusty RA files down from their shelves, with no success. Having spent about an hour exhausting our list of nine RAs, Mattson and I went back to the complete list of RA titles I had prepared early in my research. We found ten more RAs that we thought might have covered Theodorsen's wing-section analysis, but none of their titles actually looked anywhere as promising as had those of our first nine. We examined the first RA on this second list-No. 236, "Investigation of wing flutter"-because we knew that its subject was one of Theodorsen's specialties. When RA 236 also proved a washout, we gave up the idea of proceeding further with our method.
I then asked Mattson which research section Theodorsen had worked in during 1929 and 1930; I knew that Theodorsen became head of the Physical Research Division when it was created in 1931, but was unsure where he had worked previously. Though Mattson did not come to work at Langley until just before World War II, he knew the older crowd and replied that he thought Theodorsen had been a member of the Atmospheric Wind Tunnel (AWT) section.
Having failed to find anything in the RA files, I now decided to look into the correspondence files for contemporary records of the AWT section. Entry into these records was easy, thanks to the alphabetized subject guide discussed above. Mattson and I looked through some letters from the late 1920s and early 1930s, and though we saw nothing dealing with Theodorsen's paper, we did see in the upper left-hand corners of many of the letters, in parentheses next to the Central File code, the numbers 88 and 237. We knew that these numbers were cross-references to RA numbers where other copies of the same document had been filed by Langley clerks. The numbers meant that the administration of much of the work being done in the AWT section during this period had been covered by RAs 88 and 237.
RA 88, "Investigation of scale effect on airfoils," and RA 237, "Investigation of lateral stability with particular reference to rotary stability at large angles of attack," did not seem to match the subject of Theodorsen's paper. Of the two RAs, however, No. 88 looked closer to it. So we got a few folders of 88 down from the shell and started looking through [574] them. We found a memo with a note penciled in at the bottom, "TR 411 changed to RA 237."
TR 411 was the published NACA technical report by Theodorsen which we were looking for, so Mattson and I knew that our hunt was over. Mattson was astonished to find where it had led, for RA 237, "Investigation of lateral stability with particular reference to rotary stability at large angles of attack," had nothing whatever to do with the subject of Theodorsen's paper. In fact, Mattson noted (and I agreed completely) that RA 237 would have been just about the last place we would have looked for the administrative records of Theodorsen's work. RA 237 covered TR 411 simply because it was an RA which was generally blanketing a number of diverse research projects then being conducted at Langley by the AWT section. Scholars wishing to use the NACA research authorization files may benefit by keeping our experience in mind.
A third important collection of historical documents in the Langley archives is the Milton Ames Collection. In the early 1970s Ames, an ex-Langley engineer who had served as chief of aerodynamics at NACA headquarters from 1949 to 1958, began research for what he hoped would be a complete and publishable history of the laboratory. Although he did not achieve his goal, Ames did pull together hundreds of significant documents. Organized into folders which he titled and deposited into seven oversize boxes, the Ames Collection is stored-according to the original box scheme and folder titles-in file cabinets in the LaRC archive.
The Ames Collection is especially enlightening because it was created by an old NACA hand, a product of the institutional culture under investigation. The documents he found significant enough to include for research tell us something about both Ames's identity as a member of the NACA "corporation" and his approach as an engineer to historical understanding. Furthermore, since Ames was one of the NACA's most talented and forward-looking aerodynamicists, his choice of key technical papers for historical examination is very helpful to the nonspecialist.
The entire collection, comprising seven boxes, is outlined below.
WRIGHT BROTHERS
ESTABLISHMENT OF BRITISH ADVISORY COMMITTEE FOR AERONAUTICS
Papers, notices, 1909 interim report, 1909-1911 report
[575] NEED FOR AN AERONAUTICAL LABORATORY IN AMERICA
From Dr. Zahm's papers, nos. 33, 34, 40, and 54
SMITHSONIAN ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON THE LANGLEY AERODYNAMICAL LABORATORY
Dr. Zahm's paper no. 53
SURVEYS OF AERONAUTICAL LABORATORIES IN EUROPE, 1913-1920
AERONAUTICAL RESEARCH IN CANADA
EARLY HISTORY OF AERONAUTICAL RESEARCH IN GERMANY
Schlichting letter listing references Hermann Schlichting, Univ. of Göttingen]
MISCELLANEOUS PAPERS ON AVIATION UP TO ESTABLISHMENT OF NACA
LEGISLATION PERTAINING TO NACA, AND APRIL 1958 SUMMARY
ESTABLISHMENT OF NACA
NACA MEMBERSHIP, CHAIRMEN, ETC.
FIRST MEETING OF NACA
Minutes and photographs of members, 1915
LANGLEY SITE SELECTION AND TRANSFER OF LAND TO NACA
NACA STATEMENT OF POLICY, OCTOBER 1917, AND EXECUTIVE ORDER DATED 20 MAY 1918
MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING WITH THE ARMY RE USE OF LANGLEY FIELD BY NACA, 1919
[576] SUMMARY OF IMPORTANT EVENTS IN EARLY HISTORY OF NACA, 1915-1917 (SUMMARY PREPARED DECEMBER 1929)
NACA PARIS OFFICE (ESTABLISHED MAY 1919)
MISCELLANEOUS PAPERS ON AERONAUTICAL RESEARCH IN USA, 1921-1925
EARLY REVIEWS AND SUMMARIES-NACA AND LANGLEY
MISCELLANEOUS LANGLEY BACKGROUND INFORMATION
LANGLEY FIELD, VIRGINIA-HISTORY AND CONSTRUCTION (AIR CORPS VIEWPOINT)
LANGLEY LAND RECORDS AND DEEDS
[577] EARLY CONSTRUCTION, LANGLEY RESEARCH STATION
DEDICATION OF LANGLEY (11 JUNE 1920)
VARIABLE DENSITY WIND TUNNEL-CONSTRUCTION
LANGLEY ORGANIZATION CHARTS
LANGLEY PERSONNEL AND PERSONNEL ACTIVITIES
[578] ESTIMATES OF LANGLEY PLANT COSTS
ECONOMIC VALUE OF NACA RESEARCH (SUMMARY, 1937)
PRELIMINARY (LANGLEY) DATA ON NACA BUDGET (1915-1952)
EFFORTS TO TRANSFER NACA FROM INDEPENDENT AGENCY TO OTHER AGENCIES
LANGLEY INSPECTIONS (ORIGINALLY CALLED MANUFACTURERS' CONFERENCES)
PHOTOGRAPHIC FILES
LOGBOOKS OF EARLY EXHIBITS
LANGLEY VISITORS' REGISTER, 1926-1934
WILBUR WRIGHT MEMORIAL LECTURES
FOLDERS ON KEY INDIVIDUALS ASSOCIATED WITH LANGLEY HISTORY
CLIPPINGS (1925-1930)
1933 HURRICANE
SPECIAL PUBLICATIONS-ANNIVERSARIES, HISTORIES
CONFERENCES, CEREMONIES, INSPECTIONS, VISITORS
ECONOMIC STUDY OF 1933 AND "NOTES ON AVIATION PROGRESS THROUGH RESEARCH"
LANGLEY HISTORY (COLLECTION OF PAPERS AND TALKS ON LANGLEY HISTORY)
MISCELLANEOUS PRESS RELEASES ON LANGLEY RESEARCH ACTIVITIES
MISCELLANEOUS CORRESPONDENCE REGARDING EARLY HEADQUARTERS-LANGLEY RELATIONSHIP
LANGLEY TELEPHONE DIRECTORIES, JAN. 1963 TO MAY 1971
EARLY ENGINE COMPETITION (1920)
FATAL AIRCRAFT ACCIDENT REPORT, JN-6 44946, 20 AUGUST 1924
FORD RELIABILITY TOUR, 1926
CRASH OF THE "AMERICAN LEGION" AT LANGLEY, 26 APRIL 1927
RESEARCH ACTIVITIES DURING 1920s
NACA PREPARATIONS PRIOR TO WORLD WAR II
Policy regarding laboratory in time of war (George Lewis's memorandum dated 1 Dec. 1936 for chairman of special committee on policy regarding membership of employees in military reserves)
Westover Committee report to NACA chairman, 19 Aug. 1938; subject: Relation of the NACA to national defense in time of war
Initial report of Air Corps-NACA committee making recommendations for priority of research projects in LMAL program, 22 Dec. 1939
Authorization to the NACA's director of aeronautical research from the NACA executive committee to carry out investigations for the army and navy for the duration of the war, and to issue research authorizations as required
John F. Victory letter to NACA laboratories regarding views of high government officials on the NACA, 17 Feb. 1943
NACA library listing of references pertaining to NACA preparation for war and support of World War II
LANGLEY CONTRIBUTIONS TO AMES AND LEWIS LABORATORIES
LANGLEY ACTIVITIES DURING WORLD WAR II ERA
MEAD COMMITTEE INVESTIGATION-ORIGINAL CORRESPONDENCE
U.S. Senate special committee investigating the national defense program, 1946
NATIONAL AERONAUTICAL RESEARCH POLICY, 21 MARCH 1946
POST-WORLD WAR II RESEARCH ACTIVITIES
GAO SURVEY OF NACA, 1953
25TH ANNIVERSARY OF LANGLEY TOWING TANK AND FULL-SCALE WIND TUNNEL, 1956
NATIONAL AWARDS TO LANGLEY
EXTRA COPIES OF "AIR SCOOP"
MISCELLANEOUS AIRSHIP PHOTOGRAPHS FROM MELVIN N. COUGH
AREA RULE AND RICHARD WHITCOMB
LANGLEY CONTRIBUTIONS TO B-58
V /STOL RESEARCH
HIGH-SPEED SUBMARINE "ALBACORE" RESEARCH FOR U.S. NAVY
RESEARCH ON FLEXIBLE WINGS
LANGLEY SPECIAL GROUP ON RESEARCH FOR GUIDED MISSILES
LANGLEY RESEARCH FACILITIES
"NACA RESEARCH INTO SPACE," 1957
"ECHO I" AND WILLIAM J. O'SULLIVAN
EARLY MANNED SPACE FLIGHT
PROJECT APOLLO
PAPERS AND TALKS RELATING TO HISTORY OF LANGLEY
The Floyd L. Thompson Collection. Actually this collection holds more for the space historian than it does for the aeronautical historian. Most of its contents postdate the NACA; they derive from Thompson's term as director of the NASA Langley Research Center, 1960-1968. Box C of this collection, though, contains some important documents on NACA research dating back to the 1930s. (Thompson began working for the NACA at Langley in July 1926.) The entire collection of papers was donated to the LaRC archive in 1980 by Thompson's widow, Mrs. Jean Thompson. The following reproduces Floyd Thompson's own inventory of the subjects of the collection.
EARLY SPACE PROGRAM PLANNING: MEMOS AND ORGANIZATIONS VISITS AND EVENTS
NEWPORT NEWS CYCLOTRON AND VARC (Virginia Associated Research Campus)
SPECIAL ASSIGNMENTS
OLD LANGLEY FLIGHT RESEARCH PROGRAMS
HISTORICAL NOTES ON FLYING QUALITIES WORK
OLD CONFERENCE MEMOS AND HISTORICAL NOTES ON DYNAMIC LOADS AND STRUCTURES RESEARCH
TRANSONIC RESEARCH
NOTES, COMMENTS, STATEMENTS ON MANAGEMENT PHILOSOPHY
AERONAUTICS POLICY, 1970
LANGLEY'S 50TH ANNIVERSARY
ROTARY CLUB TALKS
LOCAL AFFAIRS
UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN HONORARY DOCTORATE
WILLIAM AND MARY HONORARY DOCTORATE
[584] RETIREMENT PARTY, 17 OCT. 1968
PERSONAL MATTERS, INCLUDING CORRESPONDENCE REGARDING APPOINTMENT AS CENTER DIRECTOR
NOTES ON OTHER PERSONS
MISCELLANEOUS TECHNICAL REPORTS AND PAPERS
COPIES OF PUBLIC TALKS, PUBLICITY STATEMENTS, PHOTOS
LETTER TO NATIONAL ACADEMY OF ENGINEERING
NUMEROUS TECHNICAL ARTICLES AND PAPERS, MOSTLY PUBLISHED
The John Stack Collection. This collection is more valuable to the aeronautical historian than is the Thompson collection because it includes a greater number and wider chronological range of older business correspondence and research program files-many of which concern Stack's pioneering work in transonic and supersonic technology. The papers were donated to the Langley archives by Stack's son, Peter, who, like Mrs. Thompson, chose to keep several of the more private letters in the family's possession, at least for the time being. The papers, which are in folders labeled by John Stack, have been organized into sections of file drawers according to categories:
TFX DEVELOPMENT
MISCELLANEOUS PHOTOGRAPHS
BLUEPRINT DRAWINGS
"STACK'S STUFF," MISCELLANEOUS
What really makes Langley one of the very best places in the country for research in aeronautical history is the technical library in which the historical archives are located. Besides holding major collections (over 3.8 million volumes) in the physical sciences and engineering with emphasis in aerospace science and technology, aeronautics, structures, materials, acoustics, energy, electronics, and the environment, and [588] besides holding supporting collections in physics, chemistry, mathematics, and management, the library also preserves the complete NACA publications series-over 16,000 reports in more than 1000 bound and nearly 2000 unbound volumes-including Technical Reports (TRs), Technical Notes (TNs), Technical Memorandums (TMs), Wartime Reports (WRs), Aircraft Circulars (ACs), Research Memorandums (RMs), Advance Confidential Reports (ACRs), Advance Restricted Reports (ARRs), Confidential Bulletins (CBs), Restricted Bulletins (RBs), and Memorandum Reports (MRs). (For an analysis of the NACA publications series, see Roland, Model Research, app. G, pp. 551-567.)
What gives the library its unparalleled strength as a place for historical research, though, is the fact that its staff maintains the same index to aeronautical literature that was begun by the NACA in the 1920s. Cards reference tens of thousands of aeronautical papers from all over the world by subject, author, title, and, in the case of NACA reports and research authorizations, by number. Many of these papers are unpublished or classified. This makes the NACA card file one of this country's most treasured guides to aeronautical information. Langley's file is all the more precious because it is the only set extant.
The library is accredited and open to the public.
Photographic Collection. Langley's collection of photographs (housed separately from the library) runs to roughly 100,000 negatives, all of which are logged by date and by subject. The motion picture film collection (part of which is housed in the library and part in the separate photographic laboratory in building 1155) is also extensive, but most of the films are not in any shape to be loaned out for exhibition. There is a subject card file to this motion picture collection.
Anyone interested in conducting historical research at Langley should contact Richard T. Layman, Historical Program Coordinator, Mail Stop 123 (telephone 804/865-3688), or Sue K. Seward, reference librarian, Mail Stop 185 (804/865-2634), Langley Research Center, Hampton, Virginia 23665.